|
Why should dissenting ideas about anything be shut out of the Market Place of Ideas, the Free Exchange of Dissenting Views?
Every
single person reading these words, whether they know it or not, is a Vendor of
Ideas. Each of us possesses a host of ideas on many subjects. We like to call
them opinions, points-of-view, or positions we take. They comprise everything
from what we believe about God to how we view the origins of homosexuality. We
all have ideologies. Some of us have ideologies formed out of the processes of
critical thinking. We’ve resorted to principles of sound, rational thought, and
logic to come up with what we believe.
Then, there
are those who fly by the seats of their pants and depend on the shifting sands
of emotions to form their ideologies. They feel, therefore, what they believe
is right—to them.
No matter
how you’ve formed your ideology, your world-view, when you express what that
ideology is, you become a Vendor of Ideas. Whether we got our ideology
from the process of sound thought or from silly subjectivism, when we express
what we believe about anything, we are trying to sell our ideas to those who
will listen.
The place
where we do this is in the Market Place of Ideas where our ideas, our
philosophies, our theologies compete with other ideas for examination or
scrutiny. What is so vital, so critically important in a true and thriving
democracy, is that in this Market Place of Ideas, Truth collides with Error. It
is in this Market Place where Right confronts Wrong. It is in this Market Place
where a proper and sound epistemology surfaces and shows you whether you’ve
been thinking rightly about what you are trying sell in the Market Place of
Ideas.
The Market
Place of Ideas, that place where the best test of truth is conducted, that place
where the power of thought is used to get one’s ideas accepted, where
propositions collide in heartfelt civil discourse between two competing ideas,
is no longer as open as it use to be. It is, in fact, closed in favor of
enforcing a kind of fascism
in which those with ideas now rebel against Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity.
The ideas
of Christianity, the origins of homosexuality, the true motive behind abortion,
and much more, are but three concepts that have been closed out of the Market
Place of Ideas.
If you try
to take a position on any of these concepts, present them in the Market Place
of Ideas, or attempt a meaningful debate in any venue, you are hammered.
What is the
non-Christian so afraid of in the Market Place of Ideas in discussing the
Gospel of Jesus Christ and debating whether man is a sinner and in need of a
Savior? What is so appalling about that?
What is the
homosexual so afraid of in the Market Place of Ideas in which a discussion is
undertaken to examine the evidence whether or not homosexuality is genetic or
whether it is a choice? Why is that challenge a hate-crime? Why is someone
homophobic for offering dissent? Why does the homosexual close the door to
Market Place of Ideas as though all the evidence is in their favor? The jury is
still out on this issue. The organized and politically savvy Gay Movement knows
how to keep this fact out of the Market Place of Ideas where the truth about
the origins of homosexuality would collide with the error of their position.
Why do the
abortion activists resist helping women have their unwanted babies and then
adopting those children out? The years-long waiting lists for couples wanting
to adopt children could be shortened if N.O.W. would put its energy and efforts
into securing financial support for women to have their children for couples to
eagerly adopt. Why is this idea closed out of the free exchange of the Market
Place of Ideas?
When one
attempts to offer any dissent whatsoever in these three areas, this dissent is
met with the door to the Market Place of Ideas slammed in their faces. One’s
right to free expression is denied.
The dissenter is threatened, or even
harmed, for his dissenting view by the political crowd who determines truth by
a majority vote instead of by critical thought and an exchange of ideas.
The dissenter is denied fraternity for his dissenting view.
You can know you’ve crossed the fascism threshold when you,
Are
so insanely possessed by the politically correct view of the majority, a
view not arrived at by a careful and well-articulated argument, that you
want to squash and suppress anyone who dissents from and contradicts your
ideas. You
wish harm, wish death, threaten, or do anything in word, thought, or deed
to those who dissent against your ideas. You stop treating the person as
an equal.
You
stop loving your dissenting neighbor as yourself. You deny fraternity to
the one who dissents with your positions and ideas.
That is
what fascism is all about, is it not?
It is a
rebellion, ideologically, against Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity.
A fascist
is one who denies someone liberty, equality, and fraternity all because that
person offers a dissenting view in the free exchange of ideologies in the
Market Place of Ideas.
Which are
you?
Doug Bower
|